Top 7 Picks: Best Pacifiers For Breastfed Baby

(Last Updated On: December 11, 2018)

Babies can be so picky when it comes to their pacifiers, especially when they’re breastfed! After months being fed by you, they don’t want some fake pacifier. They want something as close to real as possible. The most suitable pacifiers will help wean them off while keeping everyone calm.

Read: Here are the best nursing covers to try

What To Look Out For

If you’re shopping for that perfect pacifier, there’s a lot you can look at. No matter what type you get though, here are some things to watch out for.

High Quality Materials

Anything you buy should be BPA free, made of something strong like silicone, and durable. You don’t want it to break after all the biting, washing, and dropping.


Babies don’t want to suck on something that’s stiff and solid! Lots of pacifiers are bendy and soft- perfect for baby.


A pacifier should be easy for your kiddo to hold in their mouth. Some pacifiers are too slippery for this, or don’t have handles for when your baby can grab.


Don’t buy the cheapest thing out there. Otherwise, you’ll have to keep buying more pacifiers! Get one that can withstand high temperatures, sterilization, and some biting when your baby’s teeth start to come in.


Obviously, you want something that you can wash easily. Anything that can be thrown in the dishwasher or sterilized is ideal.

My Top 7 Best Pacifier For Breastfed Baby

Searching online is much easier than searching in the store, but you still have so many options when it comes to your pacifier. Especially if your baby is breastfed, take a look at the top picks here.

WubbaNub Infant Pacifier

The WubbaNub is not only adorable, but also durable and one piece, so there are no hidden germs. It may not be suggested for teething, although it does help your baby adjust.

Why It’s So Popular:
– The giraffe is both adorable and distracting
– You don’t lose the four-legged animals easily
– Easy for babies to grab a hold of

Keep In Mind:
– The giraffe can be a little hard to hold since it’s so floppy

MAM Orthodontic Pacifier

The anti-slip texture helps the MAM stay in your baby’s mouth. It’s ideal for jaw development and even has air holes for the skin. Get this- it’s glow in the dark too!

Why It’s So Popular:
– Very cute design- glows in the dark
– Extremely well made and durable
– Soft nipple with a great shape

Keep In Mind:
– Not that easy to clean
– The nipple can catch water inside

NUK Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier

The orthodontic shape helps calm your baby when they transition to a pacifier. The nipple cavity lets them move their tongue while allowing for proper alignment of the teeth and palate.

Why It’s So Popular:
– Don’t leave any lines around the baby’s face
– Hold up to a lot of washing in the dishwasher
– Babies are able to hold them in their mouths really well

Keep In Mind:
– The front part could be a little shorter

Natursutten BPA-Free Natural Rubber Pacifier

The Natursutten is made completely from natural rubber, so you can be sure it’s safe and won’t leave marks on your baby’s face. It’s very hygienic too, with no cracks for bacteria to hide in.

Why It’s So Popular:
– Soft and pliable; similar to a real nipple
– No nipple confusion
– Nipple is shorter and smaller for easy latching

Keep In Mind:
– Rubs a lot on the baby’s nose
– Tends to dry out easily

Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Pacifier

Get a Tommee Tippee for a girl or a boy with these pacifiers designed specifically for teething and acceptance even from a breastfed child. The symmetrical shape is perfect for the teeth too.

Why It’s So Popular:
– Very lifelike; no nipple confusion
– Helps babies relax and sleep easily
– The nipple portion is unique and easily fits in baby’s mouth

Keep In Mind:
– No option for ordering a specific design
– The designs come off easily

BabyHuggle Monkey Pacifier

The orthodontic shape and shield helps your baby’s skin and teeth, but this pacifier can be attached to a cute monkey plush too. It’ll certainly help your baby adjust with its design that’s meant to soothe and comfort.

Why It’s So Popular:
– You can attach the monkey to any other pacifier you have
– The monkey is lightweight and has a clip at the tail
– Perfect weight and size to grab

Keep In Mind:
– The Velcro is weak, so the pacifier can falls off quite easily
– The monkey plush is a bit stiff
– The clip snap comes off easily and can be a choking hazard

Orthodontic Natural Rubber Pacifier

This natural rubber pacifier is made completely without chemical softeners or colorants. It’s completely healthy with a shape that should really comfort your baby, and even comes in a triple pack!

Why It’s So Popular:
– The pack of three is really worth the price
– Made from a single mold, so pieces won’t break off
– Soft, flexible, and fits easily in baby’s mouth

Keep In Mind:
– Fairly gummy; sometimes attracts dust and dirt
– The brim covers baby’s nose

Tips On Using A Pacifier

No need to be confused when you start weaning your baby onto a pacifier. These tips will make things a whole lot simpler.

Sanitize Regularly

With all the dropping, biting, and sucking, pacifiers inevitably end up with germs. Sanitize weekly by just tossing it in the dishwasher, boiling it in a pot of hot water, or putting it in a sanitizing kit. Do this especially when it drops, and maybe just get a new one if your baby uses it when sick.

Right Size

It’s so hard to pick a pacifier sometimes because you have to choose one specifically for your baby’s age. Certain ones are too large or too small. You need it to fit perfectly or your baby won’t use it.


Don’t Wean During a Life Change

It may seem like something small to you, but that pacifier will become a comfort object to you baby. Don’t try and take it away when they’re going through something major like teething or potty training. Always wean them off either before or after.

No Sharing

With a few small kids, it’s hard to stop them from sharing completely, but try your best! Even just having different colors can help you keep track of whose pacifier is whose.

Remove Attachments

Before bed, get rid of any of those attachments that clip to your baby’s clothing. They can be a health risk, so just give them the pacifier.


It’s hard to pick a pacifier already, but it’s even harder when your breastfed baby will accept no less than the best! Choose the best pacifier for breastfed baby by looking at the list I’ve found for you. With any luck, your baby will find just the right one.

Written By
More from Sherry

Best Toothbrush for Toddlers

Shopping for your toddler's first toothbrush sounds simple enough, but it can...
Read More