Which Teether Is Good For Your Baby? 5 Natural Teething Toys To Try!

(Last Updated On: July 11, 2018)

There is no way you can miss the time when your baby starts teething – your little one will put anything in his or her tiny little mouth, from fingers to the remote control.

One of the most important toys you can buy for your baby are teething toys. They stimulate the healthier eruption of your baby’s teeth, plus they help relieve the pain and discomfort your baby is feeling. But even though it might sound easy, choosing the right or even natural teething toy for your baby can be a bit of a challenge.

How to Choose Safe Natural Teething Toys

Some babies go through their teething period with almost no drama, but most of them will experience real discomfort and pain. In order to soothe the discomfort and to make sure your baby does not keep putting in its mouth everything in hands reach – sponges, shoes and cell phones, you’ll want to get some nice teething toy. Here is what to look for:

  • Toys that contain no toxic chemicals, and are made of only natural materials
  • Toys that are easy for the baby to hold in its hands and use properly
  • Toys that have been highly-rated by other parents
  • Toys that are affordable, can fit your budget, but are well made
  • Things you should beware of when choosing teething toys

nature organic teething rings

As we discussed already, not all natural teething toys are made equally. It might sound like making a toy for this purpose is super-easy, but there still are some things to look out before choosing a safe one:

  • Beware of teethers made in China since their colors can contain lead and plastic Chinese toys sometimes contain phthalates.
  • Don’t get teething toys that are made of PVC. Polyvinyl chloride (PVC), basically is plastic that has been softened with phthalates.
  • Skip teethers that are made of any type of plastic. They can be toxic, and you don’t want to risk it, even if it says that they are BPA– and phthalate-free. Plus, all plastic is hormone disrupting.
  • Don’t opt for teething biscuits – they pose a choking hazard because they can easily break in half while in your baby’s mouth.

5 Best Teethers For Your Baby

Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether

Check price and more details here

Just like the brand states, these Comotomo Silicone Baby Teethers are baby-finger-sized. They are perfectly designed for little hands to easily grab and hold. It comes with multiple grabbing and biting points, ensuring your baby will never get bored playing with the same toy, and a safe non-choking design. The toy is made of 100% safe hygienic silicone: BPA-, PVC-, and Phthalate-free
. It is safe to wash in microwaves, boiling water, dishwashers, and sterilizers.

Why It’s So Popular:
– The perfect length to access molars without gagging the little one
– The ring at the top is just big enough to grip it with one or both hands
– Best suitable for early-eaters
– Perfect softness
– Easy to wash
– 100% safe hygienic silicone: BPA-, PVC-, and Phthalate-free

Keep In Mind:
– Too soft
– Too smooth for babies that prefer texture

Ashtonbee Natural Teething Toys Set

Check price and more details here

These teething toys are designed with Safety and Quality in mind to gently massage the tender gums of your baby. Not a single detail was overlooked to make these. Each toy in this set is made of 100% Medical Grade Silicone and has a unique surface texture to them. The toys come with a wide handle for your little one’s hands and they have absolutely no smell.

Why It’s So Popular:
– 100% SAFE for the baby – only non-toxic, BPA free and FDA approved materials
– Unique textures to each toy
– Effectively massage baby’s gums to relieve teething pains
– Pack of 5
– Good size, fits nicely into baby’s mouth
– No choking hazard
– Easy to grip
– Cute, colorful designs
– No funky smell that could irritate your baby’s nose

Keep In Mind:
– The ring is not very big

Safety 1st Mombella Elephant

Check price and more details here

This toy has been developed with the help of a pediatric specialist and is made from 100% soft and safe silicone, and nothing else. Designed to be easy for little hands to hold, the bright colors and interesting textures stimulate baby’s senses of sight and touch while alleviating the pain of teething. This sturdy teether will easily deal with both vigorous gumming and emerging teeth making it great for the different stages of teething. Dishwasher safe, it’s easy to keep this teether clean and ready for your little one to enjoy.

Why It’s So Popular:
– Gently soothes sore gums
– Textures stimulate touch
– Bright and cheerful colors stimulate vision
– Perfect size for little hands, easy to grip
– Top-rack dishwasher and freezer safe
– Really, really soft
– Very well made
– Many grip points
– Durable

Keep In Mind:
– Would be better if the tip was bigger and wider

Gertie The Good Goose Natural BPA Free Teething Toy

Check price and more details here

Gertie has been expertly sized to fit perfectly in babies’ hands and to soothe tender gums. Gertie has a lovely quack (more of a squeak) that your baby will soon identify as their special toy’s sound. She is soft to the touch, has a slight vanilla scent, and has contrasting colors for a quick and easy visual focus. Gertie is soft and light, and the simple contours make her incredibly easy for your baby to grasp and manipulate freely.

Why It’s So Popular:
– 100% safe, all-natural toy
– Fits great in baby’s hands
– Works well with soothing tender gums
– Soft to the touch
– The design improves baby’s focus
– Lightweight

Keep In Mind:
– Not good for very small babies, better suitable for late teethers
– The vanilla scent can be repelling to some

Natursutten BPA Free Natural Rubber Teether

This amazing toy is made from pure natural rubber from the tree Hevea brasiliensis. It is free of bisphenol-A (BPA), phthalate, PVC, lead, nitrosamines and any other harmful chemicals. It is a great safe alternative to conventional baby teether toys. It’s constructed with two sides of all-natural rubber, fused together by more all-natural rubber—leaving a cushion of air in between. Made in Italy by a family business that’s been manufacturing rubber baby-products for 3 generations.

Why It’s So Popular:
– All natural rubber with no paint
– Free of bisphenol-A (BPA), phthalate, PVC, lead, nitrosamines and any other harmful chemicals
– Just the right combination of softness and firmness
– Different textures on each star nub
– Very soft
– Gentle on the gums great for chewing
– Great size for baby’s hands

Keep In Mind:
– Might discolor if submerged in hot water
– The two glues pieces might break apart after some time


My motto as a parent is – you can never be too safe. The more you read and hear other parents stories, the more you will get to realize that even the simplest toys have to be safe and well made in order to maintain your baby’s health.

Written By
More from Sherry

Dr. Scholls Women’s Joliet Ballet Flats Pregnancy Shoe Review

The pair of shoes you wear while you are pregnant are extremely...
Read More